Skip to main content
PAUL CARLCARDS

SPORTS CARD CONSIGNMENT

You can stop carrying this.

I handle the research sorting, imaging, listing, shipping and customer service for you. You maximize the collection's value, receive monthly payments, and save your time.

START A CONSIGNMENTHow it works →

I KNOW WHY THIS FEELS HEAVY

Maybe it was your father's.

Maybe it's time for you to move on, or the back of your shop is buried in bulk.

Maximizing the value of a collection takes research, sorting, imaging, listing, shipping, and customer service. It is real work, and isn't worth the time for most people or even most card shops.

You don't need to sort anything. You don't need to know what you have. You don't have to sell for pennies on the dollar. Uncertainty is the first thing I take off your hands.

WHAT HAPPENS TO YOUR COLLECTION

Five stages. You'll hear from me at every one.

Before your cards arrive, you'll know exactly what to expect — and when.

ReceiveYour collection arrives and is imaged and confirmed. You'll know everything is safe before you've finished worrying.
ReviewI do any research required and create a strategy to share with you on the best way to sell everything.
ListProfessional images, honest descriptions, and intelligent pricing. Every card presented the way it deserves.
SellI handle buyers, questions, packing, shipping, and the occasional return. You watch it happen from your statement.
PayProceeds arrive on schedule, with an itemized accounting of every sale. Nothing to reconcile. Nothing to chase.

STEWARDSHIP, SHOWN

These are not my cards. They're yours. That changes how everything is done.

HANDLINGEvery card is carefully organized and stored safely upon arrival.
ACCOUNTINGEach collection gets its own ledger. You can ask where any single card is, and I can answer.
SHIPPINGPackages leave here the way I would want mine to arrive. Buyers notice. Their trust becomes your price.

NOTHING HIDDEN

Two simple rates: 25% or 60% of sale price.

25% of the sale price if your collection is already sorted by player, team, set, or year and ready to sell.
60% if it arrives as unsorted bulk and I handle the sort and prep on my end.
No upfront or hidden fees, no pressure. If I'm not your best option, I'll tell you. The only additional fee possible is for the sorting labor if you cancel the consignment agreement on an unsorted collection before 90 days.

See the full pricing page

When you're ready, tell me about your collection.

A few sentences is plenty. You'll hear back from me within one business day.

START THE CONVERSATION

No obligation. You'll know what to expect before you send anything.

RECENT ARTICLES

Guides for sellers, written plainly.

View the full library →

SELLING COLLECTIONS

The Best Way to Sell Sports Cards (For You)

There's no single best way to sell sports cards — there's a best way for your time, your timeline, and your collection. Answer three questions and know yours.

11 MIN READ · AUGUST 3, 2026